EB-1A Criteria Decoded: The 10 Criteria, How to Meet 3, and Real Profile Examples
A plain-English breakdown of all 10 EB-1A criteria, how USCIS's two-step review works, how to pick your best three, and three clearly labeled hypothetical profiles.

Introduction
A plain-English breakdown of all 10 EB-1A criteria, how USCIS's two-step review works, how to pick your best three, and three clearly labeled hypothetical profiles.
Quick answer: The EB-1A criteria are 10 types of evidence listed in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3), such as awards, judging, original contributions, scholarly articles and high salary. You need at least 3 of them, or a one-time major international award, and then USCIS decides in a final merits review whether you are at the very top of your field.
Last updated 17 November 2026. Criteria, policy and fees checked against USCIS, eCFR and court sources on that date.
Why Do So Many People Get Stuck on the EB-1A Criteria?
"eb1a criteria" was the top EB-1A search in New Jersey in the past week, and Washington, New Jersey, California and Massachusetts led U.S. interest in EB-1A, according to Google Trends data for the 7 days to 17 November 2026.
That tracks with what the criteria feel like from the inside. They are written in dense legal language, and it is hard to tell whether your own work "counts." Many strong professionals either overestimate their case or rule themselves out too early.
In this guide we decode each criterion in plain English, show you how to choose your best three, and walk through three clearly labeled illustrative profiles.
Want to know which 3 criteria you could meet today? Book an EB-1A profile review with Visa Architect and we will go through them with you.
What Is EB-1A, and Who Is It Really For?
EB-1A is the first-preference employment-based green card for people with "extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics through sustained national or international acclaim," per USCIS.
The best part for many readers: under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(1), "an alien, or any person on behalf of the alien" may file. So you can self-petition, with no job offer and no labor certification.
You also need to show you will keep working in your area of extraordinary ability, and the Policy Manual says your work must substantially benefit the United States in the future. For the full filing walkthrough, see our EB-1A visa page and our step-by-step EB-1A application guide.
How Does USCIS Actually Decide an EB-1A Case?
USCIS uses a two-step review drawn from Kazarian v. USCIS (9th Cir. 2010) and described in the USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2.
In the first step, the officer checks whether you have a one-time achievement, or evidence meeting at least 3 of the 10 criteria (or comparable evidence). They look at quality where a criterion requires it, but they do not yet decide whether you are at the top of your field.
In the second step, the final merits determination, they weigh everything together. The question is whether you have sustained national or international acclaim and are among "that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field."
Why Isn't Meeting 3 Criteria Enough?
The Policy Manual gives two telling examples. Judging the work of others, "regardless of the circumstances," should satisfy the judging criterion at step one, but step two asks how significant that judging was.
Publishing scholarly articles works the same way. It meets the authorship criterion at step one, but step two asks whether the work shows acclaim. Volume alone rarely wins a case; context and quality do.
What Are the 10 EB-1A Criteria?
This is where a table genuinely helps, so here are all ten, with what USCIS looks for and the pitfalls to avoid.
# | Criterion (USCIS wording, shortened) | What USCIS looks for | Common pitfall |
|---|---|---|---|
1 | Lesser nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards for excellence | Awards recognized beyond one employer, for excellence in your field | Internal company awards with no outside recognition |
2 | Membership in associations that demand outstanding achievement | Admission judged by recognized experts on outstanding achievement | Paid or open memberships |
3 | Published material about you in professional or major trade publications or major media | Articles about you and your work, with title, date and author | Pieces about your employer, or marketing material |
4 | Judging the work of others, individually or on a panel | Peer review, competition judging, grant or award panels | Informal code reviews or internal hiring panels presented without context |
5 | Original contributions of major significance to the field | Proof that your original work changed practice in the field | Patents or funding with no evidence of impact |
6 | Authorship of scholarly articles in professional or major trade publications or major media | Articles written for learned audiences in your field | Blog posts with no editorial standard |
7 | Display of your work at artistic exhibitions or showcases | Artistic exhibitions only | Using tech demos or trade booths for this criterion |
8 | Leading or critical role for distinguished organizations | A role central to an organization with a distinguished reputation | Senior title without proof of impact |
9 | High salary or significantly high remuneration relative to others in the field | Pay compared with reliable data for your role and location | No comparison data, or comparing with the wrong group |
10 | Commercial success in the performing arts | Box office, sales or streaming figures | Rarely relevant outside the performing arts |
Criterion names are taken from the USCIS EB-1 page; the full regulatory text is in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3).
What Does the Policy Manual Say About Awards and Press?
Awards do not need Nobel-level prestige. There is also no rule that an award must be open to the most experienced people in your field, which helps earlier-career professionals.
Published material should be about you and your work, not only your employer. Marketing material created to sell your products does not qualify, however polished it looks.
Do Patents and Funding Prove "Major Significance"?
Not automatically. Work that is funded, patented or published is not, on its own, of major significance to the field.
What helps is evidence of real-world effect. A patented technology that attracted significant attention or commercialization, for example, can help show that your contribution mattered.
How Is High Salary Judged, Especially for Founders?
High salary is compared with others in your field. A job offer or contract can show what you will earn, not just what you have earned.
For startup founders, officers consider significant funding from government, venture capital or angel investors when weighing contracts or offers. Separately, the exhibitions criterion is for artistic work only; non-artistic exhibitions count only as comparable evidence.
What If a Criterion Simply Does Not Apply to Your Job?
You can submit comparable evidence when a criterion does not readily apply to your occupation. You will need to explain why it does not apply and why your evidence is comparable.
The one exception is the one-time major international award. There is no comparable evidence for that.
Your evidence may already cover more criteria than you think. Book a session with Visa Architect and we will map your record against all 10 with you.
How Do You Pick Your Best 3 Criteria?
We start with a full inventory: every award, membership, article, review invitation, patent, product, paper, role and compensation record from the past several years. Then we score each criterion as strong, possible or missing, based on independent proof rather than self-description.
From there, choose 3 to 5 criteria to argue. Going beyond the minimum protects you if an officer rejects one. If there are gaps, judging and scholarly authorship are often the most buildable in the short term, but only when the opportunities are genuine.
Finally, write for step two. Your criteria should come together as one story of sustained acclaim, supported by independent expert letters.
What Do Real EB-1A Profiles Look Like? (Illustrative and Hypothetical)
The three profiles below are hypothetical composites written for illustration only. They are not real clients and do not predict any outcome. For real results, see Visa Architect's published case studies, such as this lead data scientist's EB-1A approval.
Illustrative Profile A: Could a Machine Learning Engineer Qualify?
Picture a senior ML engineer at a large U.S. tech company, with a master's degree and several years building recommendation systems. Possible criteria include judging (reviewing for recognized ML conferences), scholarly articles (peer-reviewed conference papers) and high salary compared with wage data for the role and metro area.
Original contributions could work too, for example an open-source library adopted by other companies, but only if that adoption can be documented. The gap is the lack of press about the engineer personally, and the contribution needs independent proof such as usage data and letters from outside users.
Three criteria look reachable here. Step two depends on showing the work matters beyond the employer.
Illustrative Profile B: What About a Startup Founder?
Now picture the co-founder and CEO of a venture-backed fintech startup, previously a product leader at a well-known company. Possible criteria include published material in major trade or business media, a leading or critical role, high remuneration (with equity and funding context, which officers can consider for founders) and startup competition or accelerator judging.
The gaps are common ones. Press must be about the founder and the work, not funding announcements written by the company, and a distinguished reputation needs independent evidence.
Founders often fit EB-1A well once the evidence has third-party validation. An O-1A can be a bridge while the record grows.
Illustrative Profile C: And a Biomedical Researcher?
Finally, picture a postdoctoral researcher in oncology with a PhD and a strong publication record. Scholarly articles and journal peer review are likely, and original contributions could be shown through findings that other groups cite and build on.
Competitive fellowships or society awards with national recognition might add an awards criterion. The gap is that citations alone do not prove major significance, so expert letters should explain specifically how other researchers used the work.
This profile is strong on criteria. If step two looks uncertain, EB-2 NIW can be a sensible parallel filing.
How Much Does EB-1A Cost, and How Long Is the Wait for India?
Here are the numbers in one place, as checked on 17 November 2026.
Item | Amount or timing |
|---|---|
Form I-140 (paper filing) | $715 |
Form I-140 (online filing) | $665 |
Asylum Program Fee, self-petitioner | $300 |
Premium processing for E11 EB-1A petitions | $2,965, action within 15 business days |
EB-1 India final action date (November 2026 Visa Bulletin) | 1 February 2023 |
EB-1 India date for filing (November 2026 Visa Bulletin) | 1 July 2024 |
Sources: USCIS G-1055, USCIS premium processing, the Visa Bulletin and the USCIS adjustment filing charts page, which designated the dates for filing chart for employment-based cases in November 2026. Rest of world EB-1 was current that month.
Ready to build your EB-1A petition the right way? Book your Visa Architect consultation, or learn more about our EB-1A visa experts.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the 10 EB-1A criteria?
Awards, selective memberships, published material about you, judging, original contributions of major significance, scholarly articles, artistic exhibitions, a leading or critical role, high salary, and commercial success in the performing arts. You need at least three, or a one-time major international award.
Is meeting 3 EB-1A criteria enough?
No. Three criteria get you through step one. USCIS then makes a final merits determination on all the evidence to decide whether you have sustained acclaim and are at the very top of your field.
Can I self-petition for EB-1A?
Yes. Under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(1), you or anyone on your behalf may file, and no job offer or labor certification is required.
What is the Kazarian two-step for EB-1A?
It is the review method from Kazarian v. USCIS (9th Cir. 2010) that USCIS uses. Officers first decide whether the criteria are met, then weigh all the evidence together in a final merits determination.
What is the EB-1A priority date for India?
In the November 2026 Visa Bulletin, the EB-1 India final action date was 1 February 2023 and the date for filing was 1 July 2024. Dates change monthly, so check the latest bulletin.
How long does EB-1A take with premium processing?
USCIS takes action on an EB-1A I-140 within 15 business days with premium processing. The green card timeline then depends on your priority date and on adjustment or consular processing.
Can software engineers qualify for EB-1A?
Yes, if the evidence shows sustained acclaim. Engineers often build cases on judging, scholarly articles, original contributions with documented adoption, critical roles and high salary.
So, How Close Are You to an EB-1A?
EB-1A is demanding, but it is also one of the few green card paths that sits entirely in your hands. The difference between a weak and a strong petition is rarely talent.
It is usually how well the evidence is chosen, documented and explained. That part we can help with.
Book a consultation with Visa Architect to decode your own criteria and find out honestly how close you are to an EB-1A filing.
Disclaimer: This article is general information, not legal advice. The profiles above are hypothetical illustrations, not real cases. Immigration rules change often. Speak with a qualified immigration attorney about your situation. Last updated 17 November 2026.
Final thoughts
The gap between a weak and a strong EB-1A petition is rarely talent. It is how well the evidence is chosen, documented and explained. Map your criteria early and build toward the final merits review.


